Most Underrated/Overrated Players in the NFL?

[G0PackG0]

Eli manning, Ben Worthlessburger overrated

 

[PackersRS]

Ecry manning, Ben Rapesburger overrated

Corrected it. Could also accept Ben GrayPenisburger.

 

[Scout200]

Cullen Jenkins = Underrated
Al Harris = Overrated
London Fletcher = Underrated
Brandon Chilliar = Overrated
Rex Ryan = almost over rated
Tony Dungy = overrated (peyton would have taken any HC to a SB win)
Osi Oooooominoraa= OVERRATED
LT=UNDERRATED
CUTLER-Overrated
Matt Hasselback-underrated
Matt Cassel-Overrated
JETS DEFENSE-OVERRATED
PACKERS D- uh oh....overrated
Brett Favre-Overrated
...i could go on, just don't feel like thinking too much right now

Wow, that's quite the list!!

-Scout

 

[packers020802]

Over: TJ Whosyourmomma
Under: Chucky Woodson.... I know he just won MVP for Def player.... but he had 2 or 3 great seasons before that and the only ones that seemed to notice were GB fans!

 

[lambeaulambo]

overrated: Chad Ochocinco
underrated: Eli Manning

 

[Pat4DaPack]

Overrated: Romo

Underrated: JerMichael Finley

 

[Croak]

Overrated = Roethlisberger. His success is largely due to the team around him.
Underrated = Witten. Doesn't get enough credit for bailing Romo's butt out of the fire frequently.

 

[profile_removed]

Overrated = T.O. Period! There was a reason he was the Number 2 receiver behind an aging Jerry Rice in Frisco!

Underrated = At this point Jermichael Finley. Outside of Green Bay nobody's heard of him yet.

 

[armand34]

McNabb, Romo, Shaub - OVERRATED

Underrated - Leon Washington

 

[Incubes12]

Overrated - Philip Rivers, Bengals WR's, Roethlisberger for sure, a year ago I'd have said Cutler too
Underrated - Lee Evans, Darren Sproles