Let's put our own grades on the players:
#1 Jordy Nelson, WR Kansas State
Kind of a surprising pick, I didn't know what to believe, but after seeing clips and reading about him, there's no question he could become a solid WR for this team, hell he might even become a playmaker, he allegedly made plays game in and game out at Kansas as a converted DB, made some spetacular plays passing as he is a former QB. It also seemed like a lot of teams had him as one of the top receivers in the draft, strange for a white guy. Nice speed on him, nice size, nice hands, good long arms, destroyed Aqib Talib. He's also a crisp routerunner. Smart.
Grade: B+
#2 Brian Brohm, QB Louisville
Absolutely loved the pick, in my opinion the top QB in the draft together with Matt Ryan. Well tutored in a WCO at Louisville, one of the top offenses. Does everything well, precise, smart, doesn't make mistakes, adequate arm, can make all the throws, big pocket passer, good leader on the field and our insurance if Rodgers gets injured (knock on wood), fails or ends up a mediocre player.
Grade: A++
#3 Patrick Lee, CB Auburn
Seems like a solid man to man corner, he's physical enough to play our bump 'n' run system and will be a nice protégé for Woodson and Harris, hopefully we will get a better 3rd CB with this guy. I would have wanted Antoine Cason or Brandon Flowers though, we could have got Flowers, but I'm not disappointed with this pick.
Grade: B-
#4 Jermichael Finley, TE Texas
Could be the steal of the draft, perhaps the most talented TE in the draft but is very raw, came out after his sophmore year (?). Seems to have a big nice frame with the possibillity of becoming even larger. Seems a little cocky but not too cocky I hope. Former basketball player, was offered a basketball scholarship but wanted to play football. Catches the ball with his hands and seems to get open, plays tough. Timed speed seems a little slow though.
Grade: B
#5 Jeremy Thompson, DE Wake Forest
From what I've heard he's a talented guy with a great motor. Wasn't a great passrusher in college though but the Packers' scouts thought he hadn't gotten the chance to be one. Was compared to Julius Peppers coming out of highschool. A nice project at DE.
Grade: B
#6 Josh Sitton, OG Central Florida
Seems like a reach to me, he was projected to go undrafted and has had a lot of problems, drunk driving and getting cut all over his body, has ADHD. Don't know if this is a guy we would want on our team, it's up to him to prove me wrong.
Grade: F
#7 Breno Giacomini, OT Louisville
Huge tackle, has technique problems and isn't as strong as you'd expect. Also has been arrested for drunk driving. Questionable pick.
Grade: D
#8 Matt Flynn, QB LSU
Lead his team to a national championship in the wake of Jamarcus Russell. Sat patiently and waited for his chance behind Russell and got it. Made the most of it without many weapons. Seems to have a lot of potential. Good pick in the 7th round, reminds me of Kurt Warner.
Grade: B+
#9 Brett Swain, WR, San Diego State
Don't know much about this kid, another white receiver. Seems to have good speed from what I've heard, 4.41 40-time, they say he has good hands. Could make the team as a slot guy. Seems like good value in the 7th, looks like they were afraid he'd be difficult to sign as a UDFA.
Grade: C
Overall draft grade: B
#1 Jordy Nelson, WR Kansas State
Kind of a surprising pick, I didn't know what to believe, but after seeing clips and reading about him, there's no question he could become a solid WR for this team, hell he might even become a playmaker, he allegedly made plays game in and game out at Kansas as a converted DB, made some spetacular plays passing as he is a former QB. It also seemed like a lot of teams had him as one of the top receivers in the draft, strange for a white guy. Nice speed on him, nice size, nice hands, good long arms, destroyed Aqib Talib. He's also a crisp routerunner. Smart.
Grade: B+
#2 Brian Brohm, QB Louisville
Absolutely loved the pick, in my opinion the top QB in the draft together with Matt Ryan. Well tutored in a WCO at Louisville, one of the top offenses. Does everything well, precise, smart, doesn't make mistakes, adequate arm, can make all the throws, big pocket passer, good leader on the field and our insurance if Rodgers gets injured (knock on wood), fails or ends up a mediocre player.
Grade: A++
#3 Patrick Lee, CB Auburn
Seems like a solid man to man corner, he's physical enough to play our bump 'n' run system and will be a nice protégé for Woodson and Harris, hopefully we will get a better 3rd CB with this guy. I would have wanted Antoine Cason or Brandon Flowers though, we could have got Flowers, but I'm not disappointed with this pick.
Grade: B-
#4 Jermichael Finley, TE Texas
Could be the steal of the draft, perhaps the most talented TE in the draft but is very raw, came out after his sophmore year (?). Seems to have a big nice frame with the possibillity of becoming even larger. Seems a little cocky but not too cocky I hope. Former basketball player, was offered a basketball scholarship but wanted to play football. Catches the ball with his hands and seems to get open, plays tough. Timed speed seems a little slow though.
Grade: B
#5 Jeremy Thompson, DE Wake Forest
From what I've heard he's a talented guy with a great motor. Wasn't a great passrusher in college though but the Packers' scouts thought he hadn't gotten the chance to be one. Was compared to Julius Peppers coming out of highschool. A nice project at DE.
Grade: B
#6 Josh Sitton, OG Central Florida
Seems like a reach to me, he was projected to go undrafted and has had a lot of problems, drunk driving and getting cut all over his body, has ADHD. Don't know if this is a guy we would want on our team, it's up to him to prove me wrong.
Grade: F
#7 Breno Giacomini, OT Louisville
Huge tackle, has technique problems and isn't as strong as you'd expect. Also has been arrested for drunk driving. Questionable pick.
Grade: D
#8 Matt Flynn, QB LSU
Lead his team to a national championship in the wake of Jamarcus Russell. Sat patiently and waited for his chance behind Russell and got it. Made the most of it without many weapons. Seems to have a lot of potential. Good pick in the 7th round, reminds me of Kurt Warner.
Grade: B+
#9 Brett Swain, WR, San Diego State
Don't know much about this kid, another white receiver. Seems to have good speed from what I've heard, 4.41 40-time, they say he has good hands. Could make the team as a slot guy. Seems like good value in the 7th, looks like they were afraid he'd be difficult to sign as a UDFA.
Grade: C
Overall draft grade: B