Just how good was Don Majkowski?

Discussion in 'Packer Fan Forum' started by Forget Favre, Oct 2, 2012.

    • Super Moderator

    longtimefan Super Moderator

    Member Since:
    Mar 6, 2005
    Message Count:
    13,917
    Location:
    Milwaukee
    Ratings Received:
    +1,778 / 50 / -5
    Packer Fan Since:
    1975
    A few mentioned that being used to losing so often, he was the majic man for us.

    He was good but hurt often...I think he could have gotten us to a SB...Actually I think we would have gotten there a little sooner than Brett did.

    Only cuz Brett needed time to mature as a player and Majic seemed (just guessing as we never know) that he was more a smarter q/b at the time than Brett was
    • Like Like x 1
    • Disagree Disagree x 1
      • Super Moderator

      longtimefan Super Moderator

      Member Since:
      Mar 6, 2005
      Message Count:
      13,917
      Location:
      Milwaukee
      Ratings Received:
      +1,778 / 50 / -5
      Packer Fan Since:
      1975

      That move was at the start of his weekly TV show

      Majik Show??
      • Super Moderator

      longtimefan Super Moderator

      Member Since:
      Mar 6, 2005
      Message Count:
      13,917
      Location:
      Milwaukee
      Ratings Received:
      +1,778 / 50 / -5
      Packer Fan Since:
      1975
      He had a different # at the start of his playing time..

      We had his agent??? comment here a while ago about it
    • Forget Favre Cheesehead

      Member Since:
      Dec 27, 2009
      Message Count:
      5,727
      Ratings Received:
      +1,498 / 6 / -4
      Well apparently with some info I came across it was Paul Horning's number 5.
      There was anticipation that it would be retired so Majik switched.
      Now I dunno if he was made to switch or if it was by choice.
    • gwh11 Cheesehead

      Member Since:
      Jul 21, 2011
      Message Count:
      222
      Ratings Received:
      +84 / 3 / -0
      Majkowski asked to wear a different number after his rookie season. He wanted a number people would associate him with, as opposed to always being reminded that he was wearing Hornung's old number. There were no plans to retire #5 at the time (although it remains in essence unofficially retired since kicker Curtis Burrow was the last to wear it in 1988).
      • Like Like x 1
      • HardRightEdge Cheesehead

        Member Since:
        Jul 28, 2012
        Message Count:
        1,379
        Location:
        Buffalo, NY
        Ratings Received:
        +602 / 16 / -3
        Packer Fan Since:
        1959
        No. His arm was shot.

        Just a question, but are we at the point where Favre's legacy needs burnishing by comparing him to Majkowski, a one season wonder? That would be sad.
      • ivo610 Cheesehead

        Member Since:
        Feb 13, 2010
        Message Count:
        13,535
        Location:
        Madison
        Ratings Received:
        +2,848 / 62 / -10
        ImageUploadedByTapatalk1349325879.364459.jpg
        You mean this jersey?
        • Like Like x 1
        • GreenBlood Banned

          Member Since:
          Aug 9, 2008
          Message Count:
          1,705
          Ratings Received:
          +660 / 41 / -3
          I think we certainly could have won a SB with Majik - at least before the injury. One thing I will say. Nobody ever threw prettier ball in a Packers uniform.
        • Forget Favre Cheesehead

          Member Since:
          Dec 27, 2009
          Message Count:
          5,727
          Ratings Received:
          +1,498 / 6 / -4
          Just like how no chick ever looked better before a track meet then the one in your sig?
        • Croak Cheesehead

          Member Since:
          Aug 15, 2010
          Message Count:
          2,461
          Ratings Received:
          +701 / 3 / -0
          If Majik had the team and coaching staff around him that Favre did AND if he could have stayed healthy, he could have won the SB against the Pats. I thought he was exciting to watch.

          Sent from my Kindle Fire using Tapatalk 2
        • FrankRizzo Cheesehead

          Member Since:
          May 2, 2010
          Message Count:
          4,226
          Location:
          Dallas
          Ratings Received:
          +994 / 22 / -3
          Yeah that 1989 season was the FIRST GOOD & EXCITING season of my lifetime, and I had been a Packer fan since the late 70's.
          Sure we had a few fun years with D*ckey to Lofton, Jefferson, and Paul Coffman. But the teams still sucked.
          1989 was the first good one. He helped us win at the great 49ers.
          Sterling Sharpe was so great.
          But Majic was clutch down the stretch of games, very fun.
          • Like Like x 1
          • Agree Agree x 1
          • Forget Favre Cheesehead

            Member Since:
            Dec 27, 2009
            Message Count:
            5,727
            Ratings Received:
            +1,498 / 6 / -4
            I think I'm getting it now.
            He brought back some hope and light after everything had been dismal and dark.
            To use a volleyball metaphore: He tipped the ball and Favre spiked it.
            Would those be pretty accurate to describe things?
          • Croak Cheesehead

            Member Since:
            Aug 15, 2010
            Message Count:
            2,461
            Ratings Received:
            +701 / 3 / -0
            I think the addition of Reggie White was the tipper.

            Sent from my Kindle Fire using Tapatalk 2
            • Like Like x 1
            • Agree Agree x 1
            • FrankRizzo Cheesehead

              Member Since:
              May 2, 2010
              Message Count:
              4,226
              Location:
              Dallas
              Ratings Received:
              +994 / 22 / -3
              I would use baseball (or adolescent boy-girl stuff) instead.
              Majkowski got us to 1st base after striking out for 2 decades. At lease he got us on base.
              Favre got us to 2nd base, and 3rd base.

              Reggie White took us home.
              • Like Like x 1
              • GreenBlood Banned

                Member Since:
                Aug 9, 2008
                Message Count:
                1,705
                Ratings Received:
                +660 / 41 / -3
                Something like that.
                • Like Like x 1
                • Croak Cheesehead

                  Member Since:
                  Aug 15, 2010
                  Message Count:
                  2,461
                  Ratings Received:
                  +701 / 3 / -0
                  I like that analogy.

                  Sent from my Kindle Fire using Tapatalk 2
                • Forget Favre Cheesehead

                  Member Since:
                  Dec 27, 2009
                  Message Count:
                  5,727
                  Ratings Received:
                  +1,498 / 6 / -4
                  I do too.

                  I'm glad a couple of ya didn't forget the Minister of D-Fence who helped us out and give him his due credit.
                  • Super Moderator

                  longtimefan Super Moderator

                  Member Since:
                  Mar 6, 2005
                  Message Count:
                  13,917
                  Location:
                  Milwaukee
                  Ratings Received:
                  +1,778 / 50 / -5
                  Packer Fan Since:
                  1975
                  Dont think anyone forgot..This was if Majic could have gotten us to the SB..Did he have the talent as Brett did to do it
                • Forget Favre Cheesehead

                  Member Since:
                  Dec 27, 2009
                  Message Count:
                  5,727
                  Ratings Received:
                  +1,498 / 6 / -4
                  Football is a team sport.
                  And even though there are stars on both sides of the ball, sometimes one gets overlooked.

                  Bringing up Reggie White creates other questions.
                  Like:
                  Was Reggie White part of the same team with Majic?
                  Could Majic still have taken the team to the SB with the defense he had?

                  I think Majic is one of those great "What if...?" questions.
                • El Guapo I Scored A Perfect "1" On The Wonderlic

                  Member Since:
                  Dec 7, 2011
                  Message Count:
                  834
                  Location:
                  Land 'O Lakes
                  Ratings Received:
                  +353 / 13 / -0
                  Packer Fan Since:
                  1976
                  Nope, I don't think that Majkowski was on the roster in '93 when Reggie played. It's important to remember how the rest of the team started to evolve (had to look this up). In that '93 draft, Ron Wolf drafted Wayne Simmons, George Teague, Earl Dotson, Mark Brunnel, and Doug Evans. All of those guys were bonafide starters (except Brunnel) that contributed to the Packers' ascent over the next few years. Brunnel was the first in a great line of Favre backups that were good enough to start elsewhere in the league, but they all provided great backup insurance in case Favre ever got hurt. Based on the acquisition of White and I would argue Mike Prior, along with that great Ron Wolf draft, things changed in a hurry.
                  • Informative Informative x 1
                  • Oshkoshpackfan Mo cheese plz

                    Member Since:
                    Aug 14, 2012
                    Message Count:
                    1,312
                    Location:
                    Jacksonville NC
                    Ratings Received:
                    +441 / 31 / -3
                    Packer Fan Since:
                    1981
                    ^ Nope the majic man was gone when the reggie white era started. QB's during the 93 season were Brett Favre and Ty Detmer. Don't remember who the 3rd string guy was. We had a good defense that year, something like 40-50 sacks and a good number of picks.....that was long ago so my memory isnt perfect.
                  • Croak Cheesehead

                    Member Since:
                    Aug 15, 2010
                    Message Count:
                    2,461
                    Ratings Received:
                    +701 / 3 / -0
                    Also, Reggie helped to recruit other players for the Packers like Santana Dotson. Once Reggie joined the team, the players in the rest of the league got the message that the Packers were serious about contending.
                    • Informative Informative x 1
                    • HardRightEdge Cheesehead

                      Member Since:
                      Jul 28, 2012
                      Message Count:
                      1,379
                      Location:
                      Buffalo, NY
                      Ratings Received:
                      +602 / 16 / -3
                      Packer Fan Since:
                      1959
                      "Helped us out" is an odd way to put it. He defined the character of the team.
                    • Forget Favre Cheesehead

                      Member Since:
                      Dec 27, 2009
                      Message Count:
                      5,727
                      Ratings Received:
                      +1,498 / 6 / -4
                      I had to fix your post for ya so it wouldn't be so harsh and arrogant.
                    • Forget Favre Cheesehead

                      Member Since:
                      Dec 27, 2009
                      Message Count:
                      5,727
                      Ratings Received:
                      +1,498 / 6 / -4
                      OK let's get back to Majic time and not go off topic of the later Packers teams and players.

                      Was any of you ever at Lambeau to see Majic in person and to feel the awesome stuff or winning ways he was bringing back after the drought?

                    Share This Page