tromadz said:
trippster said:
Packnic said:
trippster said:
And packnic, saying Favre is done because of one game after a great season is absurd.
As absurd as assuming Rodger will be great becasue of one half of a football game.
I never said Rodgers will be great. I have no idea.
Favre is done. He retired. You might not have gotten the memo.
Never said you proclaimed Rodgers would be great.
Got the Memo. Also got the memo he might come back.
I don't care if he retired and unretired 15 times. If he can help us win this year then I want him. this is our best chance to get to the SB.
Are you forgetting the TEAM MOVED ON? They drafted 2 QBs. They set Favre's jersey retirement game. They moved on. Why did they move on? Because the man retired. He said "I'm done. I won't be back."
Coming back would be one of the biggest disrespects a player could show a team.
I guess in your world someone is not allowed to change their mind.
Wait I remember about 3 years ago when You came on this forum and stated
"THAT YOU WERE DONE WITH THIS PLACE, YOU WERE NEVER GOING TO POST ON THIS FORUM AGAIN".
Yet your are still here.
If BF wants to come back, things should have been done differently, but things are what they are now.
I still think this whole thing has been blown out of proportion and Brett will stay retired, but if he really does want to come back, he will still be the best QB option The Packers have and will give the team the best chance to go to the SB.
I am not saying AR will do bad but if you have your choice of a 17 year vet, who is till at the top of his game, or a 3 year vet, who has yet to prove himself, you tell me which is the better choice.