Brees versus Rodgers by the Numbers

Discussion in 'Packer Fan Forum' started by PackwillBEback, Dec 28, 2011.

  1. morningwood Cheesehead

    Member Since:
    Jan 30, 2010
    Message Count:
    289
    Ratings Received:
    +91 / 2 / -0
    LOL at "layman's terms." Someone on the internet is starting to take things way too seriously.
  2. Greenbayphil Cheesehead

    Member Since:
    Jan 17, 2011
    Message Count:
    476
    Location:
    Glasgow, Scotland
    Ratings Received:
    +104 / 2 / -0
    your just mad that Rodgers throws a better ball :)
  3. maxlives Cheesehead

    Member Since:
    Nov 10, 2008
    Message Count:
    191
    Location:
    Baltimore, MD
    Ratings Received:
    +62 / 0 / -0
    Packer Fan Since:
    1953
    Blah, blah, blah. I am willing to bet a paycheck that ARod could care less about this individual award; the previous guy was ate up with all that crap. His eyes are on the Lombardi trophy and all these others are just distractions. Am I wrong or is there no payout associated with MVP? Why is this an important topic??
  4. Greenbayphil Cheesehead

    Member Since:
    Jan 17, 2011
    Message Count:
    476
    Location:
    Glasgow, Scotland
    Ratings Received:
    +104 / 2 / -0
    Its not as important as its being made out to be, if there wasnt the Saints fans creaming over the idea of Brees getting it then I dont think you would hear a whole lot about it on here.
    • Like Like x 1
    • Jules The Colts Fan

      Member Since:
      Feb 5, 2011
      Message Count:
      2,769
      Ratings Received:
      +764 / 10 / -0
      Brees is getting older now. They might give him a lifetime achievement MVP like they did for Kobe when Chris Paul deserved it.
      • Like Like x 1
      • Ceodore Cheesehead

        Member Since:
        Oct 12, 2011
        Message Count:
        302
        Location:
        Dixon, IL
        Ratings Received:
        +92 / 2 / -0
        I think Flynn having a great game today hurt Rodger's chances for MVP. It kindof showed that he's maybe not as "V" as say a Brees or a Peyton Manning.
      • Jules The Colts Fan

        Member Since:
        Feb 5, 2011
        Message Count:
        2,769
        Ratings Received:
        +764 / 10 / -0
        This whole argument is just ridiculous to me and I am a Colts fan. And besides one man teams don't usually win it all. They get exposed at some point. When the Colts won the SB those were some of Peyton's worst playoff games actually. The TEAM won it.

        If the Colts had a good QB I think they could have made the playoffs in an average AFC with the weapons they have.

        I also think it was nice that a guy like Rodgers doesn't care. I mean he is more then willing to let a guy on his team show his stuff. He said a few times this week he wanted Flynn to play some and that he feels he could be a good starter in this league. Thats a good team guy.
      • Greenbayphil Cheesehead

        Member Since:
        Jan 17, 2011
        Message Count:
        476
        Location:
        Glasgow, Scotland
        Ratings Received:
        +104 / 2 / -0
        If that was the case, Peyton Manning deserves it.
      • _Xyn Cheesehead

        Member Since:
        Oct 19, 2011
        Message Count:
        70
        Ratings Received:
        +7 / 1 / -1
        Rodgers played one less game, and is 15-1... This is the faded part where does stats overall mean MVP, or does someone most valuable to the team? Which in that case could shoot for Peyton Manning as MVP...

        Idk
      • GreenBlood Banned

        Member Since:
        Aug 9, 2008
        Message Count:
        1,705
        Ratings Received:
        +660 / 41 / -3
        Utter crap.
      • ivo610 Cheesehead

        Member Since:
        Feb 13, 2010
        Message Count:
        13,535
        Location:
        Madison
        Ratings Received:
        +2,848 / 62 / -10
        It was known in NFL circles that Flynn was the "best back up in the league" before this season. Not surprised he played well, but I am surprised he set records.
      • Pacal Cheesehead

        Member Since:
        Feb 25, 2011
        Message Count:
        117
        Ratings Received:
        +39 / 1 / -0
        How does somebody who didn't play become "most valuable player"?

        And should Kurt Warner have been named MVP the last few years because of Arizona's woes?
      • GreenBlood Banned

        Member Since:
        Aug 9, 2008
        Message Count:
        1,705
        Ratings Received:
        +660 / 41 / -3
      • LombardiChick Win or lose, I love this team.

        Member Since:
        Jan 17, 2011
        Message Count:
        998
        Location:
        PLANET EARTH
        Ratings Received:
        +641 / 0 / -0
        Doesn't it just show that we have a great quarterback, and a potentially great one backing him up? Where is this team with a mediocre QB? Guess I don't see how today changed the answer to that question, but the criteria for MVP seems to shift by the minute, so...eh. Guess we have to wait and see.

        One thing is for sure: Rodgers puts this team (and his backup/friend) above his own statistical success. Not so sure about the others, but...you gotta love that.
        • Like Like x 1
        • LombardiChick Win or lose, I love this team.

          Member Since:
          Jan 17, 2011
          Message Count:
          998
          Location:
          PLANET EARTH
          Ratings Received:
          +641 / 0 / -0
          They never really pulled him when they hung the sixty-burger on Indy. What was that about?
        • ExpatPacker No Longer Primed for the playoffs

          Member Since:
          Oct 26, 2011
          Message Count:
          700
          Location:
          A Galaxy Far, Far Away
          Ratings Received:
          +218 / 5 / -0
          This. It's hilarious to read how opposing fans (read Saints) and the media talking heads are now saying that Flynn's performance hurts Rodgers' chances for the MVP and "proves" that Rodgers is just a "system" QB. That makes me roll over laughing.

          Rodgers has sat out an equivalent of 2.5 games this season. Could you imagine his numbers if he had not sat out several 4th quarters (and half the 3rd quarter too, twice) and had played the full game against the Lions? He'd have broken Brady's TD record, thrown for way over 5000 yards and god knows what else.
          • Like Like x 2
          • morningwood Cheesehead

            Member Since:
            Jan 30, 2010
            Message Count:
            289
            Ratings Received:
            +91 / 2 / -0
            This is incorrect, Chase actually came in for Drew during the 3rd.
          • ExpatPacker No Longer Primed for the playoffs

            Member Since:
            Oct 26, 2011
            Message Count:
            700
            Location:
            A Galaxy Far, Far Away
            Ratings Received:
            +218 / 5 / -0
            Watch out gang, the bandwagon is really going strong I'm telling you: ARod's MVP chances have been seriously hurt by Flynn's performance. The bandwagon line is that Rodgers has benefited from the "system" and that he isn't that valuable if Flynn can come in a do what he did.

            Ummmmm....of course Rodgers f--king benefits from the "system." Like Brees doesn't? Or Brady doesn't? Stay tuned.....bet you anything Rodgers doesn't win the MVP. It will either be Brees or Rodgers-Brees C0-MVP.
          • bozz_2006 Cheesehead

            Member Since:
            Mar 24, 2006
            Message Count:
            4,425
            Location:
            Grand Forks, ND
            Ratings Received:
            +550 / 3 / -0
            Nope. If you have good coaches, it's the system. Only players with bad coaching should get MVP consideration. Then you know it's all on the player. It's the only fair way to do it.
          • morningwood Cheesehead

            Member Since:
            Jan 30, 2010
            Message Count:
            289
            Ratings Received:
            +91 / 2 / -0
            Hah, yep -- it's the best player on the worst team award.

            I do think Coach of the Year has a tedency to be the most improved team award, with a preference to rookie coaches. Not sure if history supports that theory -- but that's what it seems like.
          • neilfii Hall of Fame Fan

            Member Since:
            Jan 24, 2011
            Message Count:
            4,681
            Location:
            NW Indiana
            Ratings Received:
            +715 / 0 / -0
            Packer Fan Since:
            1965
            Perhaps they should also consider that Rodgers called the plays for Flynn in the first half -- and did an outstanding job. ;)
            • Like Like x 2
            • GreenBlood Banned

              Member Since:
              Aug 9, 2008
              Message Count:
              1,705
              Ratings Received:
              +660 / 41 / -3
              "During the 3rd"? Brees played the entire 3rd quarter except for the very last play. You try to make it sound like they pulled him somewhere in the middle of the 3rd.

              So Brees only played 15.75 games this season (excuse me... make that 15.74 games) as opposed to the 13.5 games that Rodgers played.
            • PackerChamps Cheesehead

              Member Since:
              Apr 28, 2010
              Message Count:
              42
              Ratings Received:
              +5 / 0 / -0
              My opinion is that Brady is playing with less talent, tougher environmental conditions, and has similar numbers. But again, we all have our personal opinions and Brady, Brees, and Rodgers should be in consideration.
            • PackerChamps Cheesehead

              Member Since:
              Apr 28, 2010
              Message Count:
              42
              Ratings Received:
              +5 / 0 / -0
              I think its a combination of both.
            • morningwood Cheesehead

              Member Since:
              Jan 30, 2010
              Message Count:
              289
              Ratings Received:
              +91 / 2 / -0
              Well, as long as we are rounding off then I guess we can say Drew didn't play at all in the 4th against the Giants or MN (even though he played in the first few minutes of each).

              Geez.

            Share This Page