You shouldn't be debating sports.. at all.
Lets look at some stats.
2010 Packers - (Jermichael Finley plays only 5 games.)
Aaron Rodgers : 3,922 Yards, 65.7% Completion Percentage, 28 TDs, 11 Ints, 101.2 QB Rating.
Greg Jennings : 1,265 Yards, 76 Receptions, 12 TDs
Jordy Nelson : 582 Yards...